Jessica case: Highlights of judgment

Highlights of December 18 judgment of the Delhi High Court convicting Manu Sharma in the Jessica Lal murder case:

New Delhi, Dec 20: Highlights of December 18 judgment of the Delhi High Court convicting Manu Sharma in the Jessica Lal murder case:

  • Acquittal of all the accused by the trial court caused "miscarriage of justice".
  • Trial court`s assessment of evidence was "immature and self-contradictory".
  • Trial court verdict was based on misreading of material and unsustainable.
  • High Court termed the findings of trial court as perverse.
  • High Court gives credence to the testimony of Bina Ramani, her daughter Malini and Canadian husband George Mailhot.
  • High Court says two weapon theory was a concoction which was introduced first time by the complainant Shyan Munshi, who turned hostile in the case.
  • Statement of Bina Ramani clearly shows that she had herself seen Manu Sharma shooting Jessica Lall as otherwise she had no reason to ask him why he had shot Jessica.
  • Raps special public prosecutor for deliberately making a concession that Bina Ramani was not an eye witness.
  • Holds testimony of CFSL witnesses as unworthy on two weapon theory terming their statements as "sudden emergence of the worksheet".
  • Praised Bina Ramani for chasing the culprit when other socialites did not point a little finger to apprehend him.
  • High Court held that it was Manu Sharma, who pulled out his pistol, fired two shots, one in the ceiling and the other at Jessica Lal.
  • Recovery of Manu`s Tata Safari car from Noida, which was removed from the spot by co-accused Vikas Yadav and Tony Gill established their complicity in the crime.

    Bureau Report

  • Zee News App: Read latest news of India and world, bollywood news, business updates, cricket scores, etc. Download the Zee news app now to keep up with daily breaking news and live news event coverage.
    Tags: